Requirements: Detect Invsibility from equipment or orange vial, possibly Pick Lock
Go to the prisoner at 'The Stocks', ASK PRISONER HELP
Find Joseph Hutchinson, KILL SHERIFF, GET KEYS CORPSE
Go to 'Sheriff's Office' and make sure you have 'Detect Invisibility' from a piece of equipment or an orange vial, UNLOCK BOX, GET KEY BOX
Go to the prisoner at 'The Stocks' you may need to pick a door north from 'Main Street' to get to him.
GIVE KEY PRISONER, he'll give you a bible, go to 'Ingersoll's Ordinary' or hunt <a href="/mobs/details.html?id=193">Nathaniel Ingersoll</a>, ASK NATHANIEL WITCH, GIVE BIBLE NATHANIEL, he'll give it back and tell you to go to the Pastors house.
Go to 'The Front Room' of 'Parris' Parish' to see Betty, ASK BETTY WITCH, she'll be scared, give her the bible, she relaxes, ASK BETTY WITCH, ASK BETTY HURT
Now go up and east and kill <a href="/mobs/details.html?id=157">Tituba</a> (she's a nasty one),
credit: <a href="http://www.legenddb.com">legenddb</a>